The First Budget You Cut Is Usually the Wrong One

When uncertainty hits, the owner of a business doing $1M to $5M a year tends to do the same thing. They sit down, list every expense, and cut marketing first. Payroll is untouchable, rent is fixed, suppliers won't wait. Marketing looks like the one thing that can pause for a while.
I understand the reflex. But the evidence says this is often the most expensive cut a business can make. Not because marketing is magic, but because in uncertain times customers don't disappear. They wait. And whoever they remember when the waiting ends shapes next year's revenue.
The world: squeezed margins, cautious customers
Canadian small businesses aren't facing a collapse in demand right now. They're facing a margin squeeze. In CFIB's October 2026 survey, the 12-month confidence index sits at 50.0, dead centre, and the 3-month index at 45.3 (CFIB).
In the same survey, 22% of employers plan layoffs and only 11% plan to hire, the weakest staffing intentions since the pandemic. About 70% say they can pass on only a very small part of rising fuel costs; on average, just 21%.
Costs are rising and customers won't absorb them. In that environment, cutting expenses makes sense. The real question is what to cut.
People: the customer hasn't left, they're waiting
In the Bank of Canada's survey released in October 2026, about half of consumers expect a recession within the next 12 months. Spending plans slipped further from already weak levels (Bank of Canada).
That doesn't mean people have stopped buying. They're delaying decisions, comparing prices and asking for more proof. The buyer hasn't left the table. They're just thinking more slowly.
B2B looks similar. Under the "95-5 rule" from John Dawes of the Ehrenberg-Bass Institute, in many B2B categories only about 5% of potential buyers are in the market in any given quarter; the other 95% aren't yet. Dawes derives it from companies switching their main providers roughly once every five years, and stresses it's a rule of thumb, not a precise law (explainer).
Stop reaching that 95% today, and you won't be on the list when they're ready.
The market: what happens to a brand that goes quiet
The strongest evidence here comes from Ehrenberg-Bass's "When Brands Go Dark" research. The 2023 study followed 365 US consumer brands that stopped advertising for at least a year. On average, their market share fell 10% after one year, 20% after two and 28% after three (ARF).

The finding that matters most to me: losses were more common and larger among small brands and brands already losing share (Journal of Advertising Research). A big brand can coast on the place it holds in people's memory for a while. A $1M to $5M business doesn't have that much stored memory to lean on.
Now add the current climate. When competitors go quiet, the business that stays visible gets a bigger share of attention without spending more. Keeping your voice steady means being heard more clearly in an emptying room.
Strategy: don't just cut, cut selectively
Marketing being the first cut isn't a hunch. In The CMO Survey of 308 US marketing leaders, 53.1% of executives choose cost-cutting over investing in growth when profits fall short. And when costs are cut, marketing goes before other areas 45.4% of the time (The CMO Survey).
The Harvard Business Review study "Roaring Out of Recession" shows what that reflex costs. Gulati, Nohria and Wohlgezogen studied 4,700 companies across three recessions. Companies that only cut costs had a 21% chance of emerging as leaders. Those that cut inefficiency while investing selectively in market development, R&D and assets reached 37% (Harvard Business Review).

What does that mean for a $1M to $5M business? Think in three buckets:
- Protect: visibility you know works, relationships with existing customers, and the places buyers check before deciding (your website, referrals, case studies).
- Reduce: overlapping tools, spend you can't measure, channels that don't deliver.
- Pause: campaigns that still lose money after optimization, and demand generation for work you couldn't deliver anyway.
Let's be honest: sometimes cutting is right
Most of this research comes from large companies and national brands. There's no solid study that looks specifically at $1M to $5M businesses. An owner at this size often covers payroll personally, and the cushion is much thinner.
So let me be clear: if you need to cut advertising to make payroll, cut it. No cash, no strategy. The mistake is cutting marketing first, by reflex, when cash isn't the problem.
One more thing: it isn't accurate to say ads are cheap right now. Meta's average price per ad rose 12% year over year in the first quarter of 2026 (Meta). The opportunity isn't cheap ads. It's competitors going quiet in your market.
What it means for growth
Uncertain times are when customers wait. When the waiting ends, the business they think of will be the one that didn't go silent today. For a $1M to $5M business, the right question isn't "should I cut marketing?" It's "which spending brings next year's customers, and which is just habit?"
Cut overlapping tools and unmeasured spend first. Cut the signal that keeps buyers remembering you last.
The uncertainty will pass. Who customers think of when it does is being decided now.
Sources
- CFIB Monthly Business Barometer, October 2026
- Bank of Canada, Canadian Survey of Consumer Expectations, Q3 2026
- John Dawes (Ehrenberg-Bass), the 95-5 rule: explainer
- Phua, Hartnett, Beal, Trinh and Kennedy (2023), When Brands Go Dark: A Replication and Extension, Journal of Advertising Research
- ARF summary of the study
- The CMO Survey 2026 (Duke Fuqua, Deloitte, AMA)
- Gulati, Nohria and Wohlgezogen (2010), Roaring Out of Recession, Harvard Business Review
- Meta, Q1 2026 results



